A proper audit is not a long report full of screenshots. It is a short list of questions, ordered so that early answers decide whether the later ones even matter. If tracking is broken, for example, there is no point debating bid strategy.
Here is the order I use. You can run this on your own account this afternoon.
Part 1: Is the data trustworthy?
Check which actions are primary, whether page views or clicks are counted as conversions, and whether anything is double counted.
Submit a test form and make a test call. Confirm the conversion appears once, with a sensible value.
Check the links to GA4, Merchant Center and Search Console, and confirm auto-tagging is on.
Part 2: Is the money going to the right places?
Read the last 30 to 90 days of search terms. Note how much spend went to irrelevant or low-intent queries.
Is there a negative list at all? Does it cover jobs, free, DIY and competitor terms where relevant?
Broad match with no data and no negatives is a red flag. Check what share of spend each match type takes.
Confirm "presence" targeting, and check performance by device and by location for obvious outliers.
Search campaigns should not be quietly spending on the Display Network or search partners without a reason.
Part 3: Is the structure and bidding sensible?
Are themes separated so each has its own budget and message? Or is everything in one campaign with dozens of unrelated keywords?
Automated bidding needs conversion data. Check whether the strategy matches the volume available.
Look at lost impression share due to budget versus rank. They need different fixes.
Part 4: Is the message and page converting?
Are responsive search ads using relevant headlines and a reasonable ad strength? Are call, location, price and sitelink assets set up?
Does the landing page continue what the ad promised, for the exact search that triggered it?
Test on a phone with a normal connection. Slow or cramped pages quietly waste every click.
How quickly are leads answered, and is anyone feeding results back? The best ads cannot fix a lead that is called back three days later.
What to do with the findings
Rank issues by money at stake, not by effort. Tracking and wasted spend come first, structure second, creative third. Make changes in batches, note the date of each, and give them time before judging.
If you want a second pair of eyes, I offer a free audit of your Google Ads or Meta Ads account.
Frequently Asked Questions
Want this applied to your own account?
I'll audit your Google Ads or Meta Ads setup for free and tell you exactly what is working and what isn't. No obligation, no sales pitch.